| YR | NAME | Grade | Position | School |
| 2010 | Taylor Wisman | Senior | Midfield | Northshore |
| Jon Wettack | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island | |
| Brett Mennella | Senior | Attack | Bellevue | |
| 2009 | Landon Carr | Senior | Midfield | Curtis |
| Daniel Shields | Senior | Attack | Mercer Island | |
| Sam Snow | Senior | Attack | Bainbridge | |
| 2008 | Caldwell Rohrbach | Senior | Midfield | Garfield |
| Dayton Gilbreath | Senior | Defense | Bainbridge | |
| Travis Wright | Senior | Midfield | Issaquah | |
| 2007 | Greg Mahony | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island |
| Bryan Gilbreath | Senior | LSM | Bainbridge | |
| Dylan Masi | Senior | Attack | Bainbridge | |
| 2006 | Drew Snider | Senior | Midfield | Garfield |
| Kevin Mahony | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island | |
| Jason Montoya | Senior | Goal | Garfield | |
| 2005 | David VanderHoek | Senior | Attack | Bainbridge |
| Drew Snider | Junior | Midfield | Garfield | |
| Chris Taylor | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island | |
| 2004 | Alan Chirls | Senior | Attack | Mercer Island |
| Joe Picha | Senior | Attack | Bainbridge | |
| Adam Sangeorzan | Senior | Midfield | Seattle Prep | |
| 2003 | Spencer Evans | Senior | Midfield | Bainbridge |
| Luke Larson | Senior | Attack | Mercer Island | |
| Brad Gillis | Junior | Midfield | Mercer Island | |
| 2002 | Adam Smith | Senior | Attack | Bainbridge |
| Jon Bodansky | Senior | Defense | Lakeside | |
| Andy Young | Senior | Attack | Bellevue | |
| 2001 | Geoff Thilo | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island |
| Peter Bonoff | Senior | Defense | Bainbridge | |
| Ian Redman | Senior | Attack | Lakeside | |
| 2000 | Jordan Bayly | Senior | Midfield | Eastside |
| Jeff Jorve | Senior | Defense | Lakeside | |
| David Fine | Senior | Attack | Lakeside | |
| 1999 | Jeff Pattison | Senior | Midfield | Mercer Island |
| Jordan Bayly | Junior | Midfield | Eastside | |
| 1998 | Todd Thorpe | Senior | Midfield | Curtis |
| 1997 | Mark Dingfield | Senior | Attack | Lakeside |
| 1996 | Joe Kudla | Senior | Midfield | Bellevue |
| 1995 | Bobby Beaufait | Senior | Goal | Bainbridge |
| 1994 | Bobby Hawkanson | Senior | Attack | Lakeside |
| 1993 | Michael Lewis | Senior | Midfield | Bellevue |
| 1992 | Neal McCullough | Senior | Goal | Bainbridge |
| 1991 | Rob Blethen | Senior | Defense | Bellevue |
| 1990 | Aaron Foster | Senior | Midfield | Bainbridge |
| 1989 | Andrew Carras | Senior | Midfield | Lakeside |
| 1988 | Jeff Roberts | Senior | Attack | Lakeside |
| 1987 | Jeff Liebert | Senior | Attack | Bellevue |